Explore the pros and cons of metal & shingled roofing to help you make an informed decision.

The roof of your home is the main line of defense against the elements. It withstands the Texas Sun, all types of rain as well as branches when they fall. Without a properly installed and secure roof your home is subjected to a huge number risks

In Texas you have quite a few options to cover your structures. Two of the most common types of roofing materials used are metal panels and asphalt shingles . Understand the major differences between the two & you can choose the one that is the best for your budget and home.

Types of Metal Roofing (that we recommend :)

Standing Seam Metal Panels are mechanically seamed together, with no need for screws to join the panels together. They come in single-loc or double-lock versions. Single-lock meaning they attach in 1 long joint along the long ends ; Double-loc is where they bend the long joint over again for extra strength. (The main pic above shows the 2 different locks.)

Snap-loc panels do just that, they snap together with no need for mechanically seaming (or crimping). These are a wonderful option that look just like a Standing Seam roof.

This is versus a "screw-down" metal panel, (R, U or Corrugated), with many penetrations to join them together. This option requires a re-screw & re-seal every 10 years and will cost about $800 - $2,000 depending on the size of the roof. We do not often recommend a screw-down panel due to the screws being exposed to the elements.

https://www.austinroofingandconstruction.com/MetalRoofing

Pros of Metal Roofing

Energy Savings

One of the largest benefits associated with metal roofs is that they can reduce your energy bills in the summer. This is because metal roofing panels are somewhat reflective. You can even have them painted a light color or a reflective sheen to reduce the amount of sunlight they absorb.

This can help keep your home cool in the summer, reducing how often and how long your air conditioner runs.

Durability

Another key benefit of metal roofing is that it is very durable. Metal will not crack, rip, or otherwise fall apart when exposed to the elements.

Home Value

You should also note that a metal roof can increase the overall value of your home. This is something that you should think about if you are thinking about selling your home at any point in the future.

Recyclable

Metal panels and the accessories are recyclable when disposed of. McElroy is a local manufacturer that we use. Their metal panels contain about 37% pre & post consumer recycled content.

Fewer Penetrations

Snap-loc systems are designed not to have "penetrations" to join the panels together, so no nails or screws needed. The system snaps together and then screws are used to attach the system to the structure.

Every nail or screw is a "penetration" that needs to be sealed so it doesn't allow water to seep through. These nails can "pop" and screws can "back out" leaving areas vulnerable to rains.

Weight

Metal roofing systems are lighter than shingled roofing systems.

Cons of Metal Roofing

Durable, attractive, and long-lasting, there are still a few things to note about metal roofing before you decide to put it on your home.

Cost

It can boost your home's value but metal itself is a more expensive material. This is offset by fewer repairs & replacements over the years. Metal roofs last about 50 years.

Installation

Another related consideration is that the installation process is an art-form. This can increase the amount of time that it takes to put your roof in place and can also drive up the knowledge required to install it correctly.

Types of Asphalt Shingles (that we recommend :)

3-Tab / Regular / 25-Year Shingles: These are made of a single sheet, (organic or fiberglass), that is coated with asphalt and then ceramic coated granules. Here is a video.

Architectural / Laminate / Dimensional / 30-Year Shingles: Two or three layers of single sheet shingles are combined to manufacture Architectural shingles thereby improving its performance characteristics.

Pros of Asphalt Shingles

Asphalt shingles are by far the most common type of roofing material used on residential buildings. Over 8 0% of the residential market uses asphalt shingles for their roofing.

Their widespread use isn't without merit. Asphalt shingles offer a number of benefits over other types of roofing materials, including metal roofing panels.

Value

The major draw of asphalt shingles is that they are inexpensive compared to other roofing materials. With the new 50-Year warranties they are guaranteed to last as long as a metal roof! We consider these warranties a buy one get one free program as a shingle will degrade before 50 years. The only catch is that the warranty applies to the current and next owners only, unless you pay for an additional warranty transfer.

Easy Installations and Repairs

Unlike metal roofing, asphalt shingles can be easily installed in one day for most cases. Repairs also tend to be less expensive than other roofing types.

Recyclable

Believe it or not shingles are recyclable! Asphalt recycling is economical and has end-of-life applications in pavements. Our old roofs can become part of our new roads! This helps move Austin toward it's Zero Waste goals.

Cons of Asphalt Shingles

Asphalt shingles have a few significant downsides that you should be aware of.

Heat Retention

Shingle roofs get very hot and they take a long time to cool down vs. metal that cools as soon as the sun goes down.

Durability

Our hot summers are not kind to shingles, it causes premature cracking and granule loss over time. Shingles are heavier than metal but can still be picked up by high winds. Falling branches, hail, and other environmental factors can lead to punctures.

In short, you'll likely have to do more repairs on asphalt shingles than you would on metal roofing - even if those repairs are easier and quicker to do.

Choosing Between Metal Roofing vs. Shingles Depends on Your Needs

While you can easily spot some significant differences when comparing metal roofing vs shingles, the right choice for your home will depend on your needs, budget most likely your HOA Rules :)

Of course, figuring out which roofing material is the best for your home isn't always easy. If you have any questions about which material you should install on your home, please reach out to us ! Our team of professionals have decades of experience in the roofing industry and can help you find the best material for your Texas roof.